|
Problem (in both Antigone and Medea):
What happens when the two crucial poles of human
existence are divided--within a person, within a
family, within a society?
Comedy:
the plot form that ends in marriage, in unity,
in a dance.
Tragedy:
the plot form that ends in divorce, in
separation, in death.
The two poles of experience (as defined by
Friedrich Nietzsche, following Euripides in
The Bacchae):
Apollonian
Dionysian
"masculine" "feminine"
rational
emotional
dichotomizing (given to
analysis)
binding (given to synthesis)
reductive
expansive
sees
steadily.
sees whole.
values state and social, contractual
bonds. values individual,
family, "natural" bonds.
defines justice as an ethic of
consistency. defines
justice as an "ethic of care."
Sophocles:
Fortunate they whose lives have no
taste of pain.
For those whose house is shaken by
the gods
escape no kind of doom. . . .
What madness of man, O Zeus, can
bind your power?
Not sleep can destroy it who ages
all,
nor the weariless months the gods
have set. Unaged in time
monarch you rule of Olympus'
gleaming light.
Near time, far future, and the past,
one law controls them all:
any greatness in human life brings
doom.
(Antigone, Wycoff, ll. 582-85; 602-13)
Euripides:
Zeus in Olympus is the overseer
Of many doings. Many things the
gods
Achieve beyond our judgment. What
we thought
Is not confirmed and what we thought
not god
Contrives. And so it happens in
this story.
(Medea, ll. 1415-19)
|